Tuesday, March 26, 2013

The Journalist's Guide to Media Law - Chapter 4 - Open Justice

Open Justice is a concept that the judicial process should be open to public examination.

This would mean that people should be able to sit in the courtroom and observe cases in progress.

By extension the media are seen in the same way as the rest of the public unless a magistrate has offered special privileges to a journalist such as a recording or court transcript.

"In the darkness of secrecy, sinister interest and evil in every shape have full swing. Only in proportion as publicity has place, can any of the checks applicable to judicial injustice operate. Where there is no publicity, there is no justice. Publicity is the very soul of justice. It is the keenest spur to exertion and the surest of all guards against improbity. It keeps the judge himself, while trying, under trial."

The open justice concept was tied closely to the notion that justice was compromised if conducted behind closed doors.

Today - The principle of open justice is reinforced at the highest level - that of the United Nations, Article 14 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights reads (OHCHR 1976)

"1. All persons shall be equal before the courts and tribunals. In the determination of any criminal charge against him, or of his rights and obligations in a suit at law, everyone shall be entitled to a fair and public hearing by a competent, independent and impartial tribunal established by law. The press and the public may be excluded from all or part of a trial for reasons of morals, public order (ordre public) or national security in a democratic society, or when the interest of the private lives of the parties so requires, or to the extent strictly necessary in the opinion of the court in special circumstances where publicity would prejudice the interests of justice; but any judgement rendered in a criminal case or in a suit at law shall be made public except where the interest of juvenile persons otherwise requires or the proceedings concern matrimonial disputes or the guardianship of children."
While some court proceedings may be closed to the general public most states have exemptions too allow journalists such as the Children's Court allows journalists to sit in and cover stories provided children are not named or witnesses etc.

Page 72 of the Journalists Guide to Media Law speaks of a journalist, Melissa Ketchell (23 November 1999) from the Townsville Bulletin who wrote to a magistrate to be allowed access to a court involving both children and sex. The resulting story - School officer tells of 'rape' - Met the requirements by detailing the circumstances of the case without identifying any of the children involved.

In recent years the use of tape recorders has been allowed - However if permission is not first sought from the magistrate your likely to be seen as contempt of court.

Thursday, March 21, 2013

Freedom of Information Request

This was the first assignment completed for JN2310 that was a Freedom of Information request. The assignment required the user to investigate a story or a matter that would lead to requesting information from a government agency or department via submitting a Freedom of Information request.

The assignment completed suggests that there may be an issue with the time taken for grievances within the Queensland Ambulance and Fire service is not satisfactory.

Read the assignment here with certain parts omitted for security and safety of those that have completed the assessment.

FOI Request Letter Example

Tuesday, March 19, 2013

Open Justice & Court Contempt

Open justice is a principle not a right.

The judicial process should be transparent and open to public examination. It is a principle that can be denied or limited in both court cases and public debates (non-publication orders, suppression orders).

Limitations - Restrictions vary in different jurisdictions.

Access to Courts - Journalists have no more rights than any other citizen in a courtroom. Some privileges (at the discretion of the judge or set out in statues). Privileges include sitting at the bench press, being able to take notes, audio taping and video recording, use of social media.

Restrictions on court documents - Affidavits, Documents from committal hearings (except in NSW), Transcripts and documents related to previous cases.

Court Orders - suppression orders, non-publication orders, pseudonym orders.

Challenging restrictions on access - Can you challenge these orders, How? On what grounds? Contact the magistrate and ask for the restriction to be lifted.

Secret Justice - Mental health, alternative dispute resolutions & matters of national security.

Contempt of Court - There are five main categories.

  • Sub-judice contempt
  • Scandalising the court. 
  • Revealing the deliberations of juries
  • Contempt in the face of the court
  • Disobedience of contempt. 

Sub-judice is trial by media, ill-defined in many respects, sub-judice period from the arrest.

Revealing Deliberations - Common law prohibition on speaking to jurors after a trial.

Monday, March 18, 2013

The Journalist's Guide to Media Law - Chapter 9 - Keeping Secrets - Working with Confidentiality

The laws of confidentiality and disobedience contempt strike at the heart of a relation between a journalist and their source.

Those such as Chris Masters and Phil Dickie who exposed corruption in Queensland aruged that they could not have reported their stories adequately without the use of confidential sourced. However, some critics suggest that journalists too readily accept information on a confidential basis.

The Media, Entertainment and Arts Alliance (MEAA) reviewed what terms such as 'on the record' and 'off the record' or 'background only' meant when sourcing information.

The following are the basic definitions of the three main terms:

  • on the record - Information that can be attributed to the source by name. 
  • on background - Information able to be used but not attributed to the source by name. 
  • off the record - Not to be used. 
Tips for Journalists: 
  • Beware of relationships of confidence - Taking information off the record is not like wearing some badge of honour, infact it's evidence that you did not try hard enough.
  • Negotiate confidentiality with your sources. Make sure your sources know the difference between 'off the record' and 'background.' Base your negotiations on such definitions as defined above by the MEAA.
  • Inform your editor or news director if your about to publish a story using a confidential source as they are responsible for the publication and deserve to have the opportunity to weigh up all the risks. 
  • Inform your lawyers - Lawyers will help you avoid a situation where you could be standing in a witness box refusing to answers questions regarding your sources.
  • Don't keep notes on off-the-record conversations and be careful not to leave a trail of telephone and email records to your source. 
  • Beware of information 'falling off the back of a truck.' If you don't know where the information has come from, you have to question it's credibility and motives and check with your lawyers and editors for breaches of confidence.
  • Use FOI laws to effect - Despite the obvious shortcoming the patient use of FOI can save a great deal of angst over confidentiality issues. You are protected from revealing a source if you have the relevant documents issued under a FOI request.
  • Be patient - Information that is confidential one day may be on-record the next after someone else reveals it or it is mentioned in court or parliament. Sometimes it's wiser to wait for someone to reveal it in court or parliament. 
Where is the Australian journalist's ethical obligation to sources stated? In the MEAA's 'Code of Ethics.' It sates: Aim to attribute information to its source. Where a source seeks anonymity, do not agree without first considering the source's motives and any alternative attributable source. Where confidences are accepted, respect them in all circumstances.

The Journalist's Guide to Media Law - Chapter 9 - Keeping Secrets - FOI Legislation

Journalists may be able to bypass issues related to disobedience contempt and confidentiality if they have the time and resources to lordge a Freedom of Information (FOI) request for government information. First introduced by Federal government in 1982 and in 2006 applied to all states and territories.

In QLD the FOI act is, Freedom of Information Act 2009.

FOI is the principle that there is a strong public interest in the administrative decisions of governments. The theory is that government documents regarding an individual should be released for free to that person, while other documents are available for a fee.

The idea behind the FOI system is that government departments become transparent by allowing the release of documents. However there are several government organisations that are exempt from the act for fear of leaking documents that could effect or cause damage to Australia's security or defence interests. Some organisations that are exempt include ASIS, ASIO, the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security (IGIS), the Office of National Assessments and some Defence sectors.

Problems with FOR

The Australian Press Council identified five key shortcoming or failures of FOI legislation:

  • Many requests are obstructed on the grounds they are unreasonably divert an agency's resources. 
  • Time delays discouraged FOI requests.
  • Costs of filing applications were prohibitive. 
  • Too many exemptions greatly reduced the amount of information available. 
  • Arbitrary decisions by FOI officers on classification of documents often hindered requests.

Friday, March 8, 2013

Week Two - Intro to Broadcast Journalism

Terms 

media houses - Covers stations/corps i.e. SCA. 
media ingest - Consumer or absorb something.
multi-platform - Many ways of sending reports.
digital workflow - How TV newsroom timetable or method is affected. 
media meshing - blogs, websites, apps, online etc. 

Radio News Bulletin Exercise for SCA Radio News (Regional - Townsville) 

Ergon Energy jobs may be on the line in Townsville amid concerns that Ergon could be privatised, leaving a new $60 million office building mostly empty. 

Townsville Chamber of Commerce president Dawson Wilkie said the State Government has "pushed for regionalisation." 

In - "We'd like to think they will continue down that path and not see services centralised back to Brisbane." 

Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez... will be embalmed following his funeral. Vice-President Nicolas Maduro said his body would be embalmed "like Lenin and Mao Zedong." World leaders will be attending his funeral later today. 

Facebook has launched a new version of their Android and IOS apps. Facebook's project lead engineer Chris Struhar said the changes to the news feed will make each post more "engaging." Though critiques have claimed the re-designing provides more space for adverts.

In Sport - The Cowboys have extended a helping hand to the Townsville Fire. The Cowboys have offered $1000 to assist with getting the girls to Melbourne early. Fire guard Mia Newley said the team’s so grateful for the support.

"Giving us the money to get down there early and giving us the greatest preparation we can have for a really big game is huge." 

Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Tutorial One - Know your Terms

Update this later...

The way a case works...

Drug dealer spent $1 million at casino: Police  Read more: http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/drug-dealer-spent-1-million-at-casino-police-20120605-1zto1.html#ixzz2Mj773Ylj 
  1. The Crime / (Offence) - The drug syndicates were under investigation for various drug charges, guns were seized as well.
  2. The Arrest - Happened on the morning of the 5 June at 6am. 
  3. The Charged - Various drug charges.
  4. Remand - The 19 faced court on the 6 June.
  5. Committal -
  6. Trial - After the trial is over the final details of the story can be given.
Legal Restrictions - Not naming the allegeded defendants, not giving out exact addressed, a broad timeline is given rather than specifying exact times of the offences.


Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Lecture Two - The Legal System in Australia & It's Court System

The legal system in Australia is derived from the British system. It has a separation of power.

Separation of Power

  • Judiciary (courts) - Interprets the law
  • Legislature (parliaments) - makes the law
  • Executive (government and public service) - puts the law into operation. 

Common law is also known as judge-made law or case law. It's the unwritten laws derived from the traditional law of England, which has been developed by the courts. (Common Law made over centuries)


The High Court is the highest court in Australia. 

The high court can change the outcome of a case they are not bound to determining the outcome of a case by looking at previous cases. The high court can reappraise its decisions in terms of common convenience and welfare of society. 

The High Court can reinterpret legal principles, i.e. the High Court can re-adapt laws to suit a changing society. 

Why is the concept of Precedence so important for journalists to understand? (Tutorial Question) 

Criminal law 

Criminal Law acts are wrongs that are considered so serious as to be an offense against the whole community. 

Civil Law 

Are all the laws that are not covered by criminal law. (from road accidents to libel actions) 

Civil actions can be settled by a judge or magistrate alone. 

Copyrights (Commonwealth law)
Defamation (State law) 

Quasi-Judicial Bodies - Can be a temporary or permanent commission. Staff of investigation and commissioners. They are given the power to interview, record. A report is put together that provides recommendations to the government that is than taken into consideration. 

Alternative dispute resolution - Arbitration, negotiation and mediation, cheaper alternatives, no court involved. Not a public case, it's done behind closed doors in a meeting style setting. 

Court hierarchies are important to understand because of the Doctrine of Precedent. 

Law of Precedent - 'Stand by the thing decided and do not disturb the calm'

NM2301 - Introduction to Web Design

Skills from this subject enable you to develop skills in website design, creation and assessment.

Develop skills in front end website development. 
Develop skills in collaborating with IT people to create more complicated websites.


  • First assignment a simple functional website - Assignment 1 Due Thursday March 26. (Week 2) (20%)
  • Develop an eCommerce site. (Week 4) (50%)
  • Research Project - Design documents for a portfolio website, creative, commercial or a journalism oriented site. Research and develop a design mock-up on the system. (30%) 
The complexity of the Web design space in the industry is managed through collaboration
We do the same thing. 



Benefits

Concentrate on your area of study while getting introduced to other disciplines. 

Technologies
  • Apple MAC (Or PC with DW CS6) 
  • HTML and CSS
  • IT contributed skills in: PHP, JavaScript and CSS. 
Website Design ~ A fusion of graphic design, information architecture and navigation design. 

Sunday, March 3, 2013

The Journalist's Guide to Media Law - Chapter 3 - Freedom of the Press

Freedom of the Press was a movement that began with the invention of the printing press.

The book mentions official censorship was imposed via a licensing system for printers that had been introduced in 1530. The first major backlash against this came in 1644, when political philosopher and poet John Milton penned Areopagitica, a speech to the parliament appealing for freedom of the press.

The Foundation of freedom of the press was laid in England during the 16th and 17th centuries (Milton and Locke).

In the US liberal ideals expounded by men similar to Milton and Locke found their way into the first ammendment to the US Constitution has enshrined freedom of the press to this day:

"Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances."

In Australia there is no equivalent to the First Amendment to the US Constitution to allow freedom of the press. However, in recent years the high Court of Australia handed down a series of decisions recognising an implied freedom to communicate on matters of government.

The first sort of ammendment to allow Freedom of Speech in Australia was in the 1990s. The High Court ruled the Australian Constitution contains an implied, but limited, right to freedom of speech on topics of political discussion.

The chapter covers allot of areas mainly through looking at cases over the years.

  • The 1994: Establishing a constitutional defence to defamation.
  • The 1997 decisions: Reaffirming free speech but refining the interpretation.
  • 2011: Free speech versus privacy.
  • 2002: Political free speech and defamation - one or two defences. 
Press Freedom was tested during the era of terrorism. The terrorist attacks lead the US to develop the USA Patriot Act of 2001.

In Australia anti-terrorism legislation has included restrictions on reporting evidence of the activities of ASIO, communicating with terrorist organisations, reporting the existence of detention orders, new surveillance and phone-tapping powers, a rebirth of the ancient law of sedition - which prohibits the criticism of the government.

Internationally Iceland and Finland have the highest in media freedom, while Burma, Turkmenistan and North Korea occupy the bottom three places of the 195 countries assessed. 

Press Freedom Organisations: Article 19, Committee to Protect Journalists, World Press Freedom Committee.

The Journalist's Guide to Media Law - Chapter 2 - The Legal System

In Australia there are 335 specific secrecy provisions imposed on journalists with the general idea of withholding information from the public. Now while it may be difficult to remember the 335 specific secrecy provisions it is a good idea to know the main ones.

E.g. Not identifying victims of sexual assault, juvenile witness or accused or jurors. Thankfully in many cases the media establishment you work for generally has a lawyer that can go over the 'no-go' zones.

Australia's Legal System is founded by four major influences - The adoption of the British legal system since 1788, The creation of the Commonwealth in 1901, The High Court decisions are the highest forum for appeal in such matters regarding Federal laws and constitutional matters, Legislative decisions that have affected the authority of lower echelons of the court have allowed for a number of commissions and tribunals.

There are two major sources of Australian Law, Statue Law (made by politicians) and Common Law (made by judges).

The highest Statue Law are those legislation in the Federal (Commonwealth) Government. Where state and Commonwealth laws conflict, Federal laws prevail under s. 109 of the Constitution.

Over the years whole bodies of law have developed using the doctrine of precedent. These laws form the basis of the common law which operates whenever legislation is nonexistent, imprecise in language or the scope of where it specifically preserves common law rights.

Cases are named according to the parties contesting them with a v. (standing for versuses)_ between their names.

In the case of Eddie Mabo and Queensland. This case was named as "Mabo v. Queensland" As Mabo challenged Queensland. The name of the party bringing the party before the court has their name appear before the v.

Did you know the full text of most High Court decisions are available online at www.auslii.edu.au?

Common Law legislation is at www.comlaw.gov.au.

The legal and the legislative processes can restrict or assist journalists' reporting, and they may even be the material on which they report.

Part of the Media's role when reporting is to broadcast any breach of the separation of powers brought to the attention of the public. 


The Journalsit's Guide to Media Law - Chapter 1 - Summary

The Jouranlist's guide to Media Law is a book that aims to empower journalists to understand the legal or ethical implications of making a decision.

Journalists are just like every other citizen, they are not exempt from the law and are subject to abide by the law. Journalists receive no special treatment when in court, many have been jailed over publishing inaccurate information about someone. (defamation) 

Laws that have made an exception for Journliasts are few and include the Trade Practices Act - Which exempts mainstream news organisations from laws prohibiting misleading and deceptive conduct in their content other than advertising. Another example is a 1997 amendment to the Evidence Act 1995.

The study of Law and Ethics equips journalists to apply their new found knowledge to work situations. It enables the journalists to understand the consequences of the choices they make.

Media Law and Ethics are important for journalists on at least three counts:

  • Responsibility - Journalists in Australia are endowed with a freedom to publish which is much greater than that allowed by many other societies.
  • Self-Protection - Ethical and Legal mistakes can prove costly for journalists. It can ruine their reputations and destroy their lives financially. 
  • Professionalism - Allows a journalist to test the boundaries of the law. 
Sound knowledge of laws and ethics should strengthen journalists to tackle tough stories.

In 2011 a Former Gangland lawyer sued the Herald and Weekly times for implicating her in a murder that occurred in 2004 - Read more here

Sports Tracker